Unlicensed Nintendo Games // Nintendo Vs. Tengen

Some of the major unlicensed tengen games for Nintendo Entertainment System


At the height of the Nintendo Entertainment System’s popularity in the late 1980s, Nintendo had very strict license agreements with third-party developers to only release five games per year, and that these titles would be exclusive to Nintendo for two years. Nintendo argued that this ensured high quality for consumers and they would put the “Official Nintendo Seal of Quality” sticker on each game.

Tengen was a video game publisher that was created by Atari Games, Its main focus was on computer and console games. When Nintendo designed the 10NES lock out system to prevent unauthorized games from running on its video game console, the NES, Atari began their attempts to reverse engineer the 10NES, which included monitoring communications between the console and cartridges chips, chemically peeling layers from the chip, and microscopically examining the code embodied in the chip's silicon. However, Atari was unable to sufficiently decipher its operation and thus failed to break the lock-out system.

Facts:


Atari obtained the source code for the 10NES from the Copyright Office, by falsely alleging that a copy of the code was needed in a copyright infringement action. Atari used this copy to develop its own replica of the 10NES, the Rabbit, which generated signals functionally indistinguishable from the 10NES. As Atari gained access to NES owners without Nintendo's licensing conditions, Nintendo sought a motion to enjoin Atari's alleged infringement of its copyright, which was granted by the District Court. Atari then asserted copyright misuse to defend against copyright infringement claims.

The courts found that Atari had infringed Nintendo's copyright by creating verbatim and substantially similar copies of the protected elements of the 10NES chip. Atari was unsuccessful in claiming that such copying was fair use, or that Nintendo had misused it copyright.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Pong // Magnavox Vs. Atari

Image
Gameplay screenshot of the arcade game Pong(1972) In 1972, Atari’s electronic table tennis game  Pong  became a bonafide craze—and Ralph Baer, inventor of the Magnavox Odyssey gaming console, sought legal action against Atari. Baer claimed that Atari co-founder Nolan Bushnell had copied Magnavox’s version of electronic Ping-Pong after Bushnell played the game at a Magnavox dealership demo a few months before  Pong  was released. Facts: In 1975 Ralph Baer and Magnavox, creators of the first home console system – the Magnavox Odyssey – sued Atari (and many other companies) for their clones of the Magnavox Odyssey’s ‘Tennis’ game. The Atari game in question was ‘Pong.’ Due to the patents held by Baer and Magnavox parent company Sanders Associates, and coupled with the fact that there was ample evidence of Atari founder Nolan Bushnell having played ‘Tennis’ at a product exhibition, Atari decided to settle the case outside of the courts. Other co...
Read more

Pac-Man and K.C. Munchkin // Atari Vs. Philips

Image
Gameplay screenshot for the arcade game Pac-man(1980) In the early 1980s,  Pac-Man  was the most popular video game in the world, and its manufacturers, Namco and Midway, were developing a home version port of it for the Atari 2600. But a year before Atari’s release, Magnavox and Philips Electronics debuted the video game  K.C. Munchkin , which resembled Pac-Man’s gameplay, for the Philips Videopac home console. While  K.C. Munchkin  was not a direct clone of  Pac-Man , its winding levels and its ghost-like monsters bore an uncanny resemblance to the Atari game. In 1982, Atari sued Philips for copyright infringement and an appellate court found that Philips had copied  Pac-Man . The Court’s ruling was the first to recognize how copyright law would apply to the look and feel of computer software. Facts: The court noted many differences and similarities between PAC-MAN and K.C. Munchkin, which are reproduced in their entireties be...
Read more

Donkey Kong // Universal City Studios Vs. Nintendo

Image
Gameplay screenshot for the arcade game Donkey Kong (1981) Donkey Kong  is an arcade game  released by N intendo  in 1981. An early example of the platform game  genre, the gameplay  focuses on maneuvering the main character across a series of platforms while dodging and jumping over obstacles. In the game, Mario  (originally named Mr. Video and then Jumpman) must rescue  named Pauline  (originally named Lady), from a giant ape named  Donkey Kong . The hero and ape later became two of Nintendo's most popular and recognizable characters.  Donkey Kong  is one of the most important games from the  golden age of arcade video games  as well as o ne of the most popular arcade games of all time. Universal Studios filed a lawsuit against Nintendo for copyright infringement  in 1982, claiming video game creator Shigeru Miyamoto had based  Donkey Kong ’s story and characters on  King Kong,  the movie...
Read more